Quartodecimanianism

The early Christian church had its hands full dealing with false teaching arising from within the church and governmental persecution from outside.  Despite these challenges, Christians still found time to bicker with one another.

One of the most significant internal conflicts was over the correct date for the celebration of Easter.  The early church commemorated the death of Jesus (called Pascha or Passover) and His resurrection and exaltation to heaven (called Pentecost).  The former expressed the deepest sadness, the latter exhilarating joy.  Eventually Pascha (or Easter) came to be the name covering the entire commemoration of the Holy Week.

Many Christians in the East, especially in Asia Minor (modern Turkey), began the celebration on Nisan 14, the date on the Jewish calendar when Passover is celebrated.  So, the day of the week was not fixed since Nisan 14 fell on a different day every year.  Those who held this view became known as Quartodecimanians (from the Latin for “fourteenth”).

The western church followed a different ancient tradition, always celebrating the death of Jesus on a Friday and the resurrection on Sunday.  The west calculated Easter Sunday as the first Sunday after the first full moon on or after the spring equinox, and most of the ancient church observed the holy days in this way.

Eusebius’ Ecclesiastical History preserves the recounting of a conversation in AD 155 between the famous bishop of Smyrna, Polycarp, and the bishop of Rome, Anicetus, about this question.  The two bishops shared their views and agreed to disagree on the matter.  They parted peacefully, each leading his people according to his own conscience.

Within fifty years the congenial atmosphere dissipated.  Victor I, bishop of Rome (c. AD 189-199), demanded that the churches of Asia abandon their practice of observing Nisan 14.  Polycrates, bishop of Ephesus at the time, responded that all the “great lights” who had lived in Asia—including the apostles John and Philip and Polycarp of Smyrna—had observed Nisan 14 and so his people would continue to do so.  Victor refused to hear Polycrates’ reasoning and threatened to excommunicate all the ancient churches of Asia!

The controversy was de-escalated by none other than the renowned bishop of Lyons, Irenaeus (whose name means “peace”).  Irenaeus counseled Victor of Rome not to cut off whole churches that observed ancient customs that differed from his own.  Irenaeus wrote: “And this variety in [Easter’s] observance has not originated in our time; but long before—in that of our ancestors.  It is likely that they did not hold to strict accuracy and thus formed a custom for their posterity according to their own simplicity and peculiar mode. Yet all of these lived nonetheless in peace, and we also live in peace with one another; and the disagreement in regard to the fast confirms the agreement in the faith.”  (Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History V.24.13)

The disagreements continued between the churches but the Quartodecimanian practice eventually faded in favor of the Roman practice of keeping the commemoration of the Lord’s death on [Good] Friday and His resurrection on [Easter] Sunday.  The Council of Nicea (AD 325) codified this practice as the law of the church.  Within a generation Quartodecimanians were penalized as divisive heretics.

Although the apostle Paul warned against making a big deal of such things as the observance of holidays (Colossians 2.16 cf. Romans 14.5-6), the early churches did just that—even when far greater threats loomed around them.  We scratch our heads and wonder why.

But I think of this conflict every time I hear people getting into heated discussions over paint or fabric colors in the church, or the type of lectern or musical instruments we use, or whether coffee (or water) should be permitted in the church building.  Will Christians in later centuries scratch their heads about us?